International Audits

Introduction

The CRA estimates it misses out on up to $5.1 billion in taxes each year because Canadian citizens conceal income from businesses and investment accounts they hold in other countries.

To combat this, the CRA has specialized audit teams that identify and audit Canadians with foreign assets.

In this article, we explain how the CRA identifies Canadians with foreign assets and share real cases of taxpayers who faced large international audits. We also cover how you and your clients can avoid the devastating consequences of international audits.

How Does the CRA Identify Canadians with Foreign Assets?

International tax audits are handled by the CRA’s Offshore Compliance Specialized Teams. These specialized teams have access to vast amounts of domestic and international data and use a mix of automated algorithms and manual assessments to prioritize and select taxpayers for investigation. The CRA cross-references this data against a taxpayer’s self-reported filings to identify discrepancies and select audit targets.

As part of Canada’s participation in the Common Reporting Standard, the CRA receives detailed financial information from more than 120 countries. This global agreement requires participating tax authorities to automatically exchange information, including names, birthdays, social insurance numbers, financial account details, and account balances of foreigners with assets in their country.

The Canadian Government also requires financial institutions, including banks, credit unions, loan companies, and even casinos, to report international electronic funds transfers of $10,000 or more entering or leaving the country.

Further, if a taxpayer appears to have unreported income, the CRA can conduct a net worth audit by comparing the taxpayer’s assets, spending and known sources of income to determine whether unreported income exists.

Case Examples: Lessons from International Tax Audits

In Azmayesh-Fard v Canada, Mr. Azmayesh-Fard used a Swiss bank account to try to conceal over $400,000 he earned while working in Libya. The CRA eventually discovered the account and reassessed his tax returns for 15 previous years, including penalties for failing to file the required T1134/T1135 forms. Mr. Azmayesh-Fard challenged the reassessments, arguing that he had not reported the account because his accountant never asked whether he had foreign accounts. The Federal Court of Appeal rejected this defence and upheld the reassessments and penalties.

In He v The King, the CRA used a net worth assessment to reassess four of Mr. He’s taxation years, adding more than $2.4 million in unreported income and imposing gross negligence penalties. The Tax Court rejected Mr. He’s argument that large deposits into his bank accounts were gifts and loans from family in China because Mr. He could not provide credible evidence.

In Chan v The Queen, Mr. Chan successfully refuted the CRA’s penalty assessment on a $2 million Bank of China account held in his name. He established that, although the account was legally in his name, the funds actually belonged to his father, providing the Court with documents showing that his father funded and controlled the account.

In Goldhar v The King, the Offshore Compliance Specialized Team assessed Mr. Goldhar more than $1.2 million in penalties for unreported income it believed he had earned through his toy company, which held assets in the British Virgin Islands and Hong Kong. Mr. Goldhar successfully appealed the assessment, arguing that the funds the CRA considered income were actually inter-corporate loans.

Conclusion

The CRA has a multitude of mechanisms to identify unreported foreign income and assets and has repeatedly pursued large assessments and massive penalties when it believes it has caught a Canadian concealing such income and assets.

As a result, Canadian taxpayers need to understand their obligations for reporting foreign income and assets and the CRA’s ability to identify them if they are not properly reported.

Taxpayers who have previously failed to report their foreign income and assets properly should consider filing a Voluntary Disclosure with the CRA to avoid some or all of the interest and penalties the CRA would otherwise assess if the omission is discovered before it is disclosed.

Taxpayers undergoing an international audit need to understand the seriousness of the issue and get proper, specialized advice from people experienced in responding to these types of audits.

Contact Blachford Tax Law if you are considering a Voluntary Disclosure or are subject to an international audit.

Next
Next

Gross Negligence Penalties: How We Overturned a $130k CRA Assessment